Review by Choice Review
In the recent flurry of reference publishing focused on the ancient world, this four-volume set is distinguished by its rich, comprehensive approach, solid scholarship, and accessibility to students, scholars, and interested general readers. As the first major compendium of its kind, it fills an important gap in the current scholarly literature of the ancient Near East. Drawing on both archaeological and textual sources, a large international team of the most respected scholars from numerous disciplines have contributed 189 essays on a wide range of topics. The nearly 3,000 pages of text spanning more than 4,000 years of history are divided into 11 broad subjects, which include the ancient Near East in Western thought; the environment; population; social institutions; history and culture; economy and trade; technology and artistic production; religion and science; language, writing, and literature; visual and performing arts; and retrospective essays. Included also are 46 maps, 612 photographs and line drawings, time lines comparing ancient Near Eastern civilizations, and a very useful index. Essential for all libraries supporting this topic. M. R. Dittemore Smithsonian Institution Libraries
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Booklist Review
This set is intended to be a "coherent, comprehensive, and imaginative treatment of the ancient Near East" for students and faculty at secondary schools, colleges, and universities. It consists of 189 articles arranged in 11 parts, with access tools that enable it to function as a reference work of sorts. The set was planned as a companion to Civilizations of the Ancient Mediterranean (Scribner, 1988), which has a similar format. Like the earlier set, Civilizations of the Ancient Near East is based on impeccable and innovative scholarship. Its editorial board members and contributors are from academic institutions, museums, and research centers recognized for scholarship in Near Eastern studies (the University of Pennsylvania, the Yale Babylonian Collection, the University of Chicago's Oriental Institute, the Oriental Faculty of Oxford University). Editor-in-chief Sasson is professor of religious studies at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Brief biographies of the contributors are included in the last volume of the set. The work includes the civilizations of Egypt, Syro-Palestine, Mesopotamia, Anatolia, the Arabian Peninsula, northeast Africa, and Aegean cultures such as Troy, Crete, and Rhodes. It spans the period from the invention of writing in the third millennium B.C. until the destruction of Persepolis by Alexander the Great in 330 B.C. The scope of the work is flexible enough to allow for discussion of continuing traditions as well as articles on the influence of the ancient Near East on modern and contemporary culture. The 11 main parts include "Ancient Near East in Western Thought," "Environment," and "Religion and Science." Each section contains from 4 ("Population" ) to 48 ("History and Culture" ) essays. The essays bear a greater resemblance to chapters in a scholarly survey than to encyclopedia articles. They are readable, with references to ancient documents, primary sources, and current scholarship throughout. Many articles reflect recent scholarship on the role of women in ancient Near Eastern society and less-familiar topics such as artisans and craftspeople, cosmetics and grooming, and erotic art. Some articles contain tables, boxed sidebars, and reference sections, such as the glossary of textile terms included within "Textile Arts in Ancient Western Asia." The lack of brief entries may frustrate users looking for quick definitions. There are no concise articles on the Hanging Gardens of Babylon, the Trojan horse, or ziggurats, although information on these topics is included within broader articles. Each article is divided into titled sections that make it easy to scan. An index in the last volume leads readers to pertinent topics. For example, there is no separate article on mummification, but it is included as a titled section within "Death and the Afterlife in Ancient Egyptian Thought," and the index identifies the page number. Although this arrangement does not make the set ideal for quick reference, it is a pedagogical tool: users will have an opportunity to discover the context of a topic. Each article concludes with a concise bibliography of books and articles, often in the form of a bibliographic essay. A "Cultural Table of Contents" and "Timeline of Ancient Near Eastern Civilizations" enhance access to the set. The "Cultural Table of Contents" is a grid with the names of cultures along the side and the topics of the 11 parts listed along the top. It makes it easy for users to identify, for example, the titles of articles on Egypt throughout the set or on specific subjects such as "Visual and Performing Arts." The set includes 612 black-and-white photos and line drawings, 46 maps, architectural plans, and graphs. The volumes' endpapers are maps of the entire region. The extent of illustration varies; for example, the article "Palaces and Temples in Canaan and Ancient Israel" includes no illustrations while a similar article, "Palaces and Temples in Ancient Mesopotamia," includes many. There is no similar reference work on the ancient Near East. Specialized encyclopedias and dictionaries such as A Dictionary of Ancient Near Eastern Architecture by Gwendolyn Leick (Routledge, 1988) may be more suitable for quick reference in these subject areas. For example, the entry house in the above-mentioned dictionary consists of six pages of concise description of houses in the various Near Eastern cultures, while the index entry house in Civilizations of the Ancient Near East leads the reader to portions of articles in 10 different places in the set. Civilizations of the Ancient Near East is a masterful, innovative work that belongs in most academic and large public libraries. Despite its limitations for reference, most libraries will want to place it in their reference collections because of the lack of any other comprehensive reference work on the ancient Near East. (Reviewed April 15, 1996)
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Choice Review
Review by Booklist Review
