Review by Booklist Review
This huge novel is saved from overwhelming the reader by the way the author tempers his considerable erudition with an equally considerable knowledge of writing technique. The result is a narrative that is complex and disturbing yet enthralling. Psychiatrist Rafael Neruda submits to the reader his testimony about the treatment of a patient, a young man whom Dr. Neruda thought was cured but who ended up killing his wife and commiting suicide. But before relating this case history, Dr. Neruda offers a detailed explanation of his own traumatic upbringing, arguing that "the true story of a therapeutic exchange begins not with the patient's present problem but with the healer's past." From the haunting of his own soul by childhood incest and from his encounters with this young patient who obviously had not been cured, Dr. Neruda formulates a concept he calls the evil disorder. Yglesias' vast knowledge of psychotherapy is made not simply accessible but irresistable as he brings the subject down to human scale, configuring complex but credible characters who are both intelligent and troubled. For all its 700 pages, this is a marvelously compelling work, and with a big publicity push behind it, expect many requests. (Reviewed April 15, 1996)0446520055Brad Hooper
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Yglesias (Fearless; Only Children) shows great respect for the attention span of readers in an ambitious therapeutic morality tale that explores the banality of evil. In the first of the book's three sections, the narrator, psychiatrist Dr. Rafael Neruda, traces his childhood from happiness through trauma to rebirth via therapy. Yglesias does an expert turn on Neruda's disintegrating relationship with his charismatic Cuban father and his Jewish mother, who descends into insanity and incestuous abuse. (Yglesias's choice of his protagonist's given name and his parents' ethnic origins is provocative in light of his own parentage.) The second part is a case history of Gene Kenny, a patient of Neruda's, who has also suffered childhood abuse. Over the course of several yearsand several hundred pagesof careful and inspired talk therapy, Neruda manages to cure Kenny of his basic neuroses. Then, in accordance with the novel's central philosophical argument, Neruda discovers that these neuroses are part of the basic equipment of life. Kenny's "cure," it turns out, has in fact hobbled himso much so that he commits a terrible crime. Then, in the novel's third section, Neruda steps out of the protective bubble of the analytic hour and into the rubble of Kenny's life in order to discover what he did wrong and to try to make it right. Becoming a participant rather than a clinician, Neruda insinuates himself into the high-tech firm where Kenny worked. There, he discovers that the sadistically manipulative CEO and his femme fatale daughter are playing out their own incestuous psychodrama on each other and on any one who gets in their path, including Neruda. He also discovers that they're perfectly happythat, although they are textbook cases of psychological infirmity, they are, in fact, superbly functional. In short, they're evil. But Neruda insists on seeing this in medical rather than moral terms. Whether this approach is viable provides the novel with its suspensea suspense that is more conceptual than plot-driven. Yglesias renders his characters with remarkably exhaustive psychological depth. But it comes at a price. For all the clinical persuasiveness of the characterization, there's not a lot of drama. This, combined with prose that is merely functional, renders the novel, despite its significant intelligence and ambition, a long haul more satisfying in theory than in practice. Major ad/promo; film rights to 20th Century Fox. (July) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
In the latest work from Yglesias (Fearless, 4/1/93), a psychiatrist struggles with the problem of evil in this ambitious novel of ideas. Rafael Neruda, a "red-diaper baby" of the 1950s, suffers a traumatic, abusive childhood. Years later, having triumphed over his problems to become a doctor, he must confront the limits of traditional therapy when Gene Kenny, a patient he has "cured," inexplicably commits a shocking crime. Neruda's attempt to understand leads to Hyperion, Inc., the computer company where Kenny worked, and into the confidences of Stick Copley, the sadistic CEO, and Halley, his narcissistic daughter. Faced with two seemingly normal people who do great harm to others, Neruda develops a radical treatment for what he terms evil syndrome. This brilliant, richly layered novel should wind up on many lists of the year's best books. Highly recommended.-Lawrence Rungren, Merrimack Valley Lib. Consortium, Andover, Mass. (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Gripping, deep-delving psychological novel that offers a new path in analysis but can't sustain the melodrama implied in its title. Intelligent, straightforward storytelling and brilliant characterization mark each Yglesias novel. Enriched by a powerful spiritual fantasy, 1993's Fearless asked the reader how he'd act if he returned from death stripped of every mortal fear. The author's latest never steams death's mirror as strongly but does remain taut and adult while asking, Can psychiatry provide a cure for evil? The answer hangs on the inspired agility of Dr. Rafael Guillermo Neruda, once a wonderchild like Yglesias himself (who published his first novel at 16). Neruda is a well-known, respectably published child psychiatrist who runs a New York clinic for abused children. His own childhood was marked by incest and violence, a mother who bedded him as a little boy and later immolated herself, and a supremely narcissistic, demanding father of Spanish background, against whom young Rafe testified. Now, Rafe's life begins to change when he accepts Gene Kenney, a wimpy, abused, disruptive teenager, as a patient. Rafe dislikes him but treats him for over a decade. Eventually, Gene becomes head of R&D for a successful, heartless computer manufacturer. But when Rafe strips him of his last neurotic defense, the liberated but defenseless Gene can't bear his calamities and escapes through murder/suicide. This personal ``failure'' propels Rafe into hiring out as a consultant to Gene's computer company and attempting a groundbreaking cure of its ``evil'' owner and his icy, man-eating daughter, both of whom have suffered childhood trauma similar to Rafe's own. His treatment will both succeed and fail. No sentence by Yglesias is particularly memorable; it's his analysis of power and sex that draws one on. Unlike Fearless, this is not a story one lingers over. But the strong plot keeps us fascinated and reading. (Film rights to Twentieth Century Fox; author tour)
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Review by Booklist Review
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Review by Library Journal Review
Review by Kirkus Book Review
