Review by Choice Review
This major new one-volume reference work (EJ) is a worthy successor to the Encyclopedia of the Jewish Religion (EJR), which Wigoder coedited with R.J.W. Werblowsky (CH, Mar'67). The EJ is generally superior in size, aesthetics, contents, and facility of use. It is a beautifully produced volume on glossy paper, allowing the scores of full-page illustrations (many in color) to be spread throughout, in contrast to EJR's two or three folios of shiny stock with only black-and-white photos. The EJ is also about twice the size of the EJR, using larger-size paper, smaller type, and almost twice the number of pages. There is a greater use of Hebrew and Yiddish for subject headings; and numerous, separate cross-reference as well as small-capital indicators within the text send the reader to related articles. Scattered throughout, adjacent to articles, are numerous shaded "boxes" containing interesting and informative data, such as the 19 blessings of the Amidah, various rabbinic aphorisms on charity, or the key points of the Book of Habakuk. Articles range from a few lines to about a page and a half, with most in the half-column category. The articles are unsigned but the contributors are listed. Most are well-known scholars in different fields and of differing ideological backgrounds, including Reform, Orthodox, and Conservative Judaism. The articles reflect the diversity of views though, curiously, Reform is always portrayed as much more traditional than it is in reality, e.g., the article "Jewish Children" is illustrated by a doubly incongruous photo: a Reform kindergarten, in Israel, with both children and teacher wearing kipot. Until recently, Reform Judaism objected both to Zionism and to the wearing of a kipah (one was required to remove it in the temple). Nor is there any clear-cut statement of the fact that with the acceptance of patrilineal descent, Reform made a major break with both Conservative and Orthodox Judaism. A useful glossary; a somewhat less satisfactory index (in tiny type). The user instructions note that subjects with an asterisk are distinct articles, there is no explanation of the arrow, which represents both "see" and "see also" cross-references. Despite these few minor irritations, a must for every library. -D. Kranzler, Queensborough Community College, CUNY
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Library Journal Review
This one-volume work resembles the Encyclopedia of Judaica in format and approach: it has double-columned heavy stock pages, color illustrations, and an informed traditionalist outlook. It does raise issues that the Encyclopedia of Judaica , written nearly 20 years ago, could not address (for example, the ordination of women as rabbis). A nice feature of this new work is the highlighted sidebars of rabbinic and folkloric sayings, such as ``Small children can disturb your sleep, big ones your life.'' Libraries strapped for funds should probably purchase a different sort of reference work first-- The Blackwell Companion to Jewish Culture ( LJ 11/1/90)--which might have a wider general interest. Still, this book is recommended for eventual purchase (even for those libraries that have the Encyclopedia of Judaica ), as it is an excellent, up-to-date, one-volume source on the Jewish religion.-- Paul Kaplan, Highland Park P.L., Ill. (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Choice Review
Review by Library Journal Review
